Citywire for Financial Professionals
Stay connected:

View the article online at

Bank of Ireland bondholders face a haircut

Holders of the £75 million Bank of Ireland 13.375% Perpetual Subordinated Bonds are about to take a nasty haircut

Bank of Ireland bondholders face a haircut

Holders of the £75 million Bank of Ireland 13.375% Perpetual Subordinated Bonds are about to take a nasty haircut. Bank of Ireland announced that it will shortly launch a ‘liability management exercise’ in respect of its subordinated liabilities. 

This is a bond issue which is widely held by UK retail investors as well as institutions.  Subordinated bonds are amongst the last in the queue to be paid out when the issuer is in trouble.  The Bank of Ireland haircuts cover some €2.6 billion of its subordinated debt in total. Virtually all the Irish banks have been bailed out by the government following the credit crunch and are now being called upon to recapitalise by restructuring debt.

Holders of Bank of Ireland 13.375% Perpetual Subordinated Bonds can expect a payout of around 20p in the pound.  According to the statement, ‘the Bank's current expectation is that the cash prices under the exercise will be 10% of nominal for Tier 1 securities and 20% of nominal for Tier 2 securities, with no payment in respect of accrued interest.’

The bonds, which have been trading in the market in recent weeks at around 70p but have been as low as 50p or less, collapsed in price and today are trading at around 22p.  This is approximately the expected payout under the proposals from Bank of Ireland.

The announcement says that the ‘liability management exercise’ will incorporate proposals to amend the terms of the relevant bonds.  This would allow the Bank to compulsorily buy back the securities for a cash sum which would be substantially less than the cash tender terms of 10p or 20p in the pound.  The Bank may also offer an equity alternative to these bondholders which would include both a premium to the cash alternative and a payment to compensate for unpaid accrued interest.

Rik Edwards of stockbroker Collins Stewart says, ‘our understanding is that the 13.375% Perpetual Subordinated Bonds (BOI) are Tier 2 securities. Therefore we expect these bonds will be offered 20p flat of accrued for each £1 nominal, or an equity alternative plus a payment in respect of accrued interest.  Currently the accrued amounts to about 1p per bond.’

He points out that holders will probably have little option but to accept one of these offers, as the alternative is likely to be a compulsory cash offer at a much lower level. ‘The Irish government has shown it is prepared to legislate to assist Irish banks to aggressively manage down its subordinated liabilities.  Senior bondholders, meanwhile, have been guaranteed by the Irish Government, and so far remain untouched,’ he says.

‘However, bear in mind that we do not yet know for certain whether the 13.375% bonds will be included in the liability management exercise. There is also a small possibility that these bonds fall under UK rather than Irish law, and may not be subject to the lower compulsory cash offer,’ he says.

That is what bondholders are hoping. But the outlook is not good. 

As one bond expert put it, ‘this is just one tranche of subordinated debt from one Irish bank amongst many.  Similar things have been happening at other Irish banks.  Investors have held bonds in what has been known to be a bust bank for over two years now.  They can try to lobby for a better deal but whether they will get anywhere is another matter.’

Some investors are likely to be speculators who bought after the credit crunch hit and would have paid 50p or less for the bonds in the market.  Other could be long term holders who stand to lose most of their money. 

The announcement by Bank of Ireland follows moves by other Irish financial institutions, including Irish Life & Permanent and EBS Building Society which was acquired by Allied Irish Bank, which have also announced plans to impose losses of as much as 90% on junior bondholders.  This is all part of the Irish government’s plans to recapitalise its banks.

Sign in / register to view full article on one page

10 comments so far. Why not have your say?

Ian Phillips

Jun 01, 2011 at 18:42

For ‘liability management exercise’ we can read 'stuff you suckers'..........

report this

Chris Clark

Jun 01, 2011 at 20:34

Sort of brings a new meaning to "My word is my bond."

But honestly, how can anyone offer a bond at 13.375% per year? And how can anybody believe it to be safe?

report this


Jun 01, 2011 at 23:54

Surely the bank has to go into Administration before any creditor can be short changed?

report this


Jun 02, 2011 at 00:19

The 13.375% bonds were issued as Bristol and West Building Society Permanent Interest Bearing Shares. I believe B&W was acquired by BOI. At the time the PIBs were first issued the rate was high, but not exceptionally high. Other high coupon PIBs continue in existence see for example Leeds 13 3/8% PIBS recent price indication 160p per 100 p nominal.

The BOI PIBs are a UK listing, and are presumably supported by the erstwhile B&W mortgage book. One may hope that as this is a UK mortgage book held by a UK subsidiary of the BOI, that a degree of ringfencing may arise. Any other thoughts on this?

report this


Jun 02, 2011 at 07:51

@Chris Clark

I owned it for several years in my ISA, enjoyed the receipt of interest

and guess what ? I sold it in time with no loss only to learn that the bank may have problems---Sheer luck !!!!

report this

bill chilvers

Jun 02, 2011 at 10:32

HI I have a Growth Bond with the Post Office, is this affected or could be affected by the collapse of an Irish Bank. Or am I now covered underthe FSA?

I did hear that from last year these types of savings with the Post Office are protected from the st November 2010?

report this

Mark Taber

Jun 02, 2011 at 12:42

I have set-up a webpage and email communcation list for holders of the Bank of Ireland 13.375% bonds at:

report this

Darron Preston

Jun 02, 2011 at 17:09

@Chris Clark

Well, I do recall that the UK Govt issued gilts with 15% coupons... was that safe?

The coupon is purely set in relation to the prevailing interest rates at the time (plus a premium to reflect credit risk).

As for this LME - Noonan has, with this offer, as well as AIM/Anglo turned the Capital heirarchy on its head. Absolutely unbelievable.

Id thoroughly recommend anyone affected contact Mark via his (excellent IMO) website.

report this

William Bishop

Jun 05, 2011 at 09:43

Pushing too hard for extra yield in bonds is not necessarily a sound strategy, since it involves increasing risk levels for a reward that is capped. At least in equities the upside is not limited, so the risk/reward balance can be considered better.

report this

colin knights

Jun 06, 2011 at 11:54

These bonds were issued by a UK building Societty and its takeover was presunably agreed by the UK regulators. The UK Government is now giving a loan to the Irish Government to overcome theit financial problems whilst the uk taxpayers and bondholders who contributed to the loan now find themselves being further penalised.If money is available for foreign loans and aid why not protect the poor bleeding UK taxpayer/bondholder?

report this

leave a comment

Please sign in here or register here to comment. It is free to register and only takes a minute or two.

News sponsored by:

The Citywire Guide to Investment Trusts

In this guide to investment trusts, produced in association with Aberdeen Asset Management, we spoke to many of the leading experts in the field to find out more.

Watch Now

Today's articles

Tools from Citywire Money

From the Forums

+ Start a new discussion

Weekly email from The Lolly

Get simple, easy ways to make more from your money. Just enter your email address below

An error occured while subscribing your email. Please try again later.

Thank you for registering for your weekly newsletter from The Lolly.

Keep an eye out for us in your inbox, and please add to your safe senders list so we don't get junked.

Sorry, this link is not
quite ready yet