Citywire printed articles sponsored by:
View the article online at http://citywire.co.uk/money/article/a635894
Eight predictions for the Autumn Statement
Chancellor George Osborne is preparing to wield the axe again, but just what will he chop to cut government spending?
by Michelle McGagh on Nov 22, 2012 at 11:38
The chancellor’s Autumn Statement is already causing a stir, with rumours of pension relief cuts and that evergreen topic of a wealth tax, but just what can we expect from his announcement on 5 December?
Richard Mannion, national tax director at accountants Smith & Williamson, believes there will be bad news for the ‘squeezed middle’ but that chancellor George Osborne will resist tinkering with pensions tax relief, although he believes it won’t be safe for long.
1. Pensions tax relief
Everyone who saves into a pension gets tax relief on their contributions. If you are a basic rate taxpayer you receive 20% relief and higher rate taxpayers receive 40%.
The 40% relief has been subject to much scrutiny and the Liberal Democrats have made it clear they want to scrap it. The argument for scrapping it is based on the fact that most tax relief is received by the wealthy who then become 20% tax payers in retirement so do not ‘pay back’ the full relief when they get their pension.
‘Cutting higher rate pensions tax relief is the little boy who cried wolf – it is always talked about and one day it will happen. My personal view is that it will not [be cut] in the Autumn Statement but is costing the country a lot of money so it is only a matter of time [before it is cut] unless we have a recovery soon,’ he said.
‘The country cannot afford to pay people’s pensions for 20 or 30 years and the relief is costing £40 billion a year [for both higher and basic relief] – it is a very valuable relief.’
2. Pension allowance
Mannion said a cut to the annual allowance for pension contributions is more likely. Each year you can save a maximum of £50,000 into a pension, or £1.5 million over your lifetime, known as the annual allowance and lifetime allowance respectively.
Although these allowances have already been cut from £255,000 and £1.8 million, they could be cut again.
‘It may be that the pensions annual allowance of £50,000 is brought down to £40,000,’ said Mannion.
He added that the government may also have its eye on the ‘very generous’ carry-forward allowance. If you have not used any or all of your annual allowance in the past three years then you can carry it forward – meaning you can save up to to £200,000 in one year (£50,000 for each of the three years you have not contributed plus £50,000 for the current year).
Hargreaves Lansdown head of pension research Tom McPhail agreed that a cut in the annual allowance was more likely.
‘If there is a change, a reduction in the annual allowance is the most likely outcome but we can’t rule out a restriction on the rate of tax relief, in spite of the additional complexity this would inflict on investors,’ he said.
3. Wealth tax
The coalition has battled it out over a wealth tax; the Lib Dems wanted one but the Conservatives didn’t and it looked like the Tories had won, until now.
Although a mansion tax on properties worth £2 million or more has been ruled out there could be a re-jig of council tax bands to ensure those with higher-value properties pay more, said Mannion.
‘There is talk about moving the bands used for council tax because at the moment a £1 million house pays the same rate as a £20 million house. However, this will be seen as a London tax and [mayor] Boris [Johnson] will have a lot to say about it,’ he said.
Mannion added that council tax bands have not been updated since 1991 and because there are no resources to overhaul the system the councils may say that if your property was worth ‘X’ in 1991 it is now worth ‘X’ more – essentially using guesswork to determine the current value.
‘The question is who will get the money, councils collect and use it but it is central government that wants it,’ he said, adding that the government could take any extra that is made on a change to council tax bands.
Osborne (pictured) is under pressure to use the Autumn Statement to kick-start the economy. Although there have been efforts to cut red tape for businesses and there is talk of using pension funds to invest in infrastructure, the truth is we have a £48 billion black-hole that needs to be filled.
Mannion believes the only way to do this is through more cuts.
‘It is never going to be as good as it used to be. If you look at the world as one big pot, then look at the Bric (Brazil, Russia, India and China) countries – they are taking more [of the manufacturing roles and business] and that means that there has to be someone getting less,’ he said.
‘We have not made anything in years and are trading in invisibles – we are a small player in a global economy.
‘If you have a shortfall you either need to spend less or bring in more and I am not sure where more will come from.’
Mannion added that there are a significant number of people in the UK who are not working and predicted benefit cuts are on the way.
The Social Market Foundation and the Royal Society of Arts said that the ‘small print’ of the March Budget suggested there would need to be an extra £26 billion of cuts but with the economic situation faltering there would have to be a further £22 billion of cuts.
5. Squeezed middle
The middle-classes feeling the pain of child benefit tax cuts and high petrol prices will not get any respite soon.
Although the masses would like to see the super-rich take a hammering, for the government it is more profitable to tax a larger number of people.
‘Everyone will have to take some pain somewhere. Everyone says "tax the rich" but it is not as good for the government as taxing the middle class because there are more of them. It is a numbers game,’ said Mannion (pictured).
6. Income tax
Income tax has already been tinkered with in the March Budget, and although there has been rumours that those earning £150,000 or more will again have their income tax reduced back to 40p from 45p, Mannion does not believe it will happen.
However, this also means that an increase in the threshold for the tax bands is also unlikely to happen. In the March Budget the government announced the phasing in of the £10,000 personal allowance for everyone by 2015/16 but it also announced a cut in the threshold for the 40% income tax rate from £42,475 to £41,450. This means that although the overall number of taxpayers will fall 300,000 more people will be pushed into the higher rate tax bracket.
7. Capital gains tax
There have been calls from the Left to increase capital gains tax (CGT) to bring it in line with income tax, like it used to be. Currently basic rate taxpayers pay 18% on capital gains over the £10,600 allowance and higher rate taxpayers pay 28%.
Mannion believes the government will leave this alone in the Autumn Statement as ‘it was part of major changes two years ago’.
8. Inheritance tax
Inheritance tax (IHT) is an emotive issue, which is why Mannion said the government won’t dare to touch it. Currently IHT is due on estates valued at over £325,000, with 40% tax paid on anything over this.
‘The Office of Tax Simplification looked at all the reliefs and said IHT was a basket case that needed completely reforming. Nothing happened and when I enquired I was told that no minister wanted to be seen as the one who changed IHT because it is such an emotional issue,’ he said.
‘It only raises £3 billion to £4 billion each year which is a drop in the bucket but it is one of the issues where the emotional reaction is inverse to the amount of money raised.’
More about this:
More from us
- Insurers to push for higher drawdown pension allowance
- Protect your pension allowance or risk 55% tax penalty
- Are you missing out on free pension money?
- Pensions guide from The Lolly
- Osborne shocks with shares-for-rights contract
- Labour plans wealth tax, and it won't be temporary
- ‘Unappealing’ outlook sustains King’s faith in QE
- Capital gains tax: what is it and do we really need it?
- Inheritance planning: how to raise this tricky topic
- Inheritance tax guide: what is a trust and how does it work?
- Don't cut income tax – tackle the high cost of living instead
- Pensioners lose a third of their income to the taxman
- Child benefit: how the new rules affect you
Weekly email from The Lolly
Get simple, easy ways to make more from your money. Just enter your email address below
An error occured while subscribing your email. Please try again later.
Thank you for registering for your weekly newsletter from The Lolly.
Keep an eye out for us in your inbox, and please add email@example.com to your safe senders list so we don't get junked.