View the article online at http://citywire.co.uk/money/article/a868039
Investment Trust Watch: ‘we’re improving’ says Alliance
Alliance Trust claims to be on the right track with performance and costs as the rating on its share price hits a new high.
Alliance Trust (ATST ) issued an end-of-year report card to shareholders this week after what has been a challenging 12 months for the Dundee-based fund.
Coming after US hedge fund Elliott Capital increased its stake to 15%, the update demonstrated how Alliance wants to be on the front foot with its largest and most hostile shareholder, which this year has forced it into a series of changes.
In the statement Alliance said it had taken action on all the targets set in October when former chief executive Katherine Garrett-Cox stepped down from the board and said it was ‘well placed for the future.’
Helped by the positive market reaction to the US interest rate rise, the shares responded with a 10p rise on Thursday. This narrowed the discount – or gap – between its share price and its net asset value to 8.4%, a 10-year low according to Morningstar data.
That increased its Z-score to 3.1, making it this week’s second most ‘expensive’ trust according to our table from Numis Securities (see below).
A Z-score is a measure used by analysts to put investment trust share prices in historical context. A trust with a Z-score of 2 or more is trading above its normal range and is therefore ‘expensive’, while a score of -2 or below shows it is beneath its normal range and is considered ‘cheap’.
|Expensive' trusts||Share price premium (- discount) to NAV %||One-year average premium (- discount) %||Z-score|
|Aurora Russia (AURR)||-23.3||-48.9||3.8|
|Alliance Trust (ATST)||-8.4||-12.1||3.1|
|RAB Special Situations (RSS)||14.6||-19.2||2.8|
|Aberforth Smaller Companies (ASL)||-3.9||-9.9||2.7|
|BlackRock Throgmorton Trust (THRG)||-8.8||-14.8||2.7|
|Jupiter European Opportunities (JEO)||4.1||1.3||2.5|
|European Real Estate (ERET)||-13.5||-36.5||2.4|
|City Natural Resources High Yield (CYN)||-9.7||-19.8||2.3|
|Standard Life UK Smaller (SLS)||-2.8||-7.8||2.3|
|Sanditon Investment (SIT)||8.7||5.0||2.1|
|BlackRock Smaller Companies (BRSC)||-5.6||-11.2||2.1|
Source: Numis Securities
Is Alliance 'expensive'?
Whether Alliance Trust is actually ‘expensive’ or not depends on whether you think it can do more to lower the discount and improve shareholder returns.
After this year’s agm I bought some shares for my pension in the hope that one way or another performance would improve. I was also attracted to Alliance Trust's stance on sustainable investment that the new managers have brought since September 2014.
So far, so good it seems. The update made a number of points:
Share buybacks: since October Alliance has purchased 4.5% of its shares in an effort to reduce the discount.
Costs: Alliance says it is on track to save £6 million next year from the investment business Garrett-Cox now runs. This comes as Rod Davidson, Alliance Trust Investments’ head of fixed income, has left the company and its small Dynamic Bond fund has been closed following Alliance Trust’s decision to sell its holdings in ATI’s bond funds.
Performance: Alliance now seeks to beat the MSCI All Country World index by at least 1% a year after fees. Since the new managers took over the net asset value of its holdings have beaten the index by 3.7%, growing 7%, although the portfolio trails the benchmark by 4.4% and 5.8% over three and five years.
However, the actual shareholder returns investors have received are ahead of the index over all time periods up to five years because the share price has benefited from the improved NAV performance and the narrowing in the discount: in short, the classic, positive double whammy of a recovering investment trust.
Over three years to 11 December its total shareholder return was 38.9% rising to 50.6% over five years. That’s still behind leading global growth trusts like Witan (WTAN ), Majedie Investments (MAJE ) and Scottish Mortgage (SMT ) but it’s getting better.
The only question is why did Garrett-Cox and her husband just sell £1.5 million shares?
|Cheap' trusts||Share price premium (- discount) to NAV %||One-year average premium (- discount) %||Z-score|
|Menhaden Capital (MHN)||-6.5||8.1||-3.4|
|NB Distressed Debt - Extended Life (NBDX)||-11.9||-6.4||-3.3|
|VPC Specialty Lending (VSL)||-8.2||1.7||-3.2|
|Africa Opportunity (AOF)||-23.3||-12.5||-3.1|
|Better Capital 2009 (BCAP)||-27.6||-17.8||-2.9|
|UK Mortgages (UKML)||3.6||6.9||-2.9|
|Advance Developing Markets (ADMF)||-14.2||-11.1||-2.9|
|GLI Finance (GLIF)||-26.6||12.3||-2.9|
|DW Catalyst - £ (DWCG)||-15.4||-4.7||-2.8|
|TR Property (TRY)||-10.3||-2.7||-2.8|
|Aberdeen Asian Income (AAIF)||-10.6||-2.8||-2.7|
|TwentyFour Income (TFIF)||-0.1||5.6||-2.7|
|Chenavari Capital Solutions (CCSL)||-7.8||2.0||-2.7|
|Hansa Trust A (HANA)||-32.4||-28.1||-2.6|
|CQS New City High Yield (NCYF)||-3.3||3.8||-2.6|
Source: Numis Securities
News sponsored by:
Making the most out of Europe's potential means seeing things differently. Learn more about how BlackRock's focused approach to investing in Europe helps investors unlock the continent's vast potential.
In this guide to investment trusts, produced in association with Aberdeen Asset Management, we spoke to many of the leading experts in the field to find out more.
More about this:
Look up the shares
Look up the investment trusts
- Aurora Russia (Ordinary Share)
- Alliance Trust (Ordinary Share)
- Aberforth Smaller Companies (Ordinary Share)
- BlackRock Throgmorton Trust (Ordinary Share)
- Jupiter European Opportunities (Ordinary Share)
- Bankers (Ordinary Share)
- European Real Estate IT (Ordinary Share)
- Standard Life UK Smaller Co. (Ordinary Share)
- Mercantile (Ordinary Share)
- Herald (Ordinary Share)
- Vinaland (Ordinary Share)
- Sanditon Investment Trust (Ordinary Share)
- BlackRock Smaller Companies (Ordinary Share)
- Menhaden Capital (Ordinary Share)
- NB Distressed Debt Extended (Ordinary Share)
- VPC Specialty Lending Invest (Ordinary Share)
- Better Capital PCC 2009 (Ordinary Share)
- UK Mortgages (Ordinary Share)
- Advance Developing Markets (Ordinary Share)
- GLI Finance (Ordinary Share)
- DW Catalyst GBP (Ordinary Share)
- TR Property (Ordinary Share)
- Aberdeen Asian Income (Ordinary Share)
- TwentyFour Income (Ordinary Share)
- Hansa Trust A (Class A Ordinary)
- CQS New City High Yield (Ordinary Share)
- Witan (Ordinary Share)
- Majedie Investments (Ordinary Share)
- Scottish Mortgage (Ordinary Share)
More from us
- Garrett-Coxes sell Alliance Trust as Elliott advances
- Alliance Trust chair Forseke exits as overhaul gathers pace
- Investment Trust Watch: Alliance splurges £64 million
- Alliance Trust splashes some cash on its shares again
- Garrett-Cox to step down from Alliance Trust board
Tools from Citywire Money
From the Forums
Weekly email from The Lolly
Get simple, easy ways to make more from your money. Just enter your email address below
An error occured while subscribing your email. Please try again later.
Thank you for registering for your weekly newsletter from The Lolly.
Keep an eye out for us in your inbox, and please add email@example.com to your safe senders list so we don't get junked.
by Jack Gilbert on Apr 25, 2017 at 11:02