View the article online at http://citywire.co.uk/money/article/a893108
Investors reject Woodford's call for more money
(Update) Volatile markets force star fund manager Neil Woodford to shelve plans for further fund raising for Patient Capital trust.
(Update) Woodford Patient Capital Trust (WPCT ) has postponed plans for a new share issue after investors rejected an appeal by fund manager Neil Woodford to back a further round of investments in early stage healthcare and technology companies.
Releasing the investment trust’s first annual results chairman Susan Searle said: ‘With the continuing uncertainty prevailing in markets, now is not an appropriate time to raise capital. The board will, however, monitor the situation and advise shareholders of any developments.’
This is a setback for Woodford who raised a record £800 million last year after the star fund manager excited investors with his vision of a low-charging, high performance fund backing British scientific innovation.
In January, having become fully invested ahead of schedule, the trust surprised investors in the midst of a New Year market meltdown with a proposal to raise more money and tap what Woodford claimed was a bigger investment opportunity than he had previously thought.
Despite the Citywire AAA-rated manager’s strong track record, that was a step too far and with many investors pulling money from other funds the appetite for a ‘C-share’ issue that could have undermined an already weak share price simply wasn’t there.
According to a survey by Woodford Investment Management just over half of shareholders in the trust said they were prepared to invest more money in its shares over the next 12 months and understood why the manager wanted to raise more funds.
However, a majority also told the company they did not understand what a C-share issue was, and were lukewarm about participating in the offer.
Low charge, no return
Today’s results show that from its launch in April until the end of 2015 its net asset value fell 2.6% to 97.38p per share, which compared well with the 7.5% decline in the FTSE All Share. This year, however, the situation has reversed with the portfolio down 8.8% compared to a 0.5% dip in the index.
Since listing at 100p the shares have fallen around 12% and trade at 88.5p, a 0.8% discount below the NAV, according to Numis Securities.
However, at the height of investor enthusiasm in August the shares peaked at 120p, a premium of 15% above the then NAV. The unravelling of the premium means that anyone who bought the shares six months ago has suffered a 22% capital loss.
There is some consolation for shareholders in that they have paid very little to Woodford for their investment. The trust levied an on-going charge of just 0.1% in 2015 and did not come close to the 10% portfolio return required for it to earn its performance fee.
In another surprise, investors will also receive a small 0.16p per share dividend as the company distributes excess investment income in order to retain its investment trust status.
That dividend is unlikely to be repeated soon as Woodford is reducing the amount of dividend-paying larger companies the trust holds and increasing the proportion of non-dividend paying start-ups.
The annual report discloses the initial 25%/25%/50% split between mid-large cap stocks, early growth companies and early-stage companies has shifted. Its investment policy is now to hold between 15-30% in both the larger and early growth categories with 40-70% in early-stage businesses.
It currently holds just under 23% in large caps, 27% in early growth and 53% in early stage firms, according to the Woodford Investment Management website. Sixty per cent of the portfolio is in publicly traded companies quoted on a stock exchange, with just over 40% in private unlisted companies such as British university spin-offs Oxford Nanopore and Proton Partners, which are harder to trade and more difficult to value but which Woodford believes have exciting potential.
In his manager’s statement Woodford urged shareholders to be patient, saying the fundamental performance of most of the trust’s holdings, such as biotechs Prothena (PRTA.O) and Vernalis (VER), had been better than expected, even if this was not reflected in their valuations.
‘The stock market is not well-endowed with patience, particularly in volatile conditions. Periodically, this manifests itself in share price weakness, especially in businesses with no earnings or dividends and relatively limited market liquidity, but therein lies the opportunity for patient capital to exploit,’ he wrote.
Its worst performing investment so far is Northwest Biotherapeutics (NWBO.O), the US cancer treatment specialist whose shares have been damaged by anonymous allegations of financial irregularities. Since 30 June its weighting in the fund has plunged from 4% to 1%. In response to pressure from Woodford the company appointed two non-executive directors last year who have overseen an inquiry, whose findings have yet to be published.
In a video on his company’s website, Woodford acknowledged that the current market was difficult but expressed his confidence that a more ‘discerning’ market would arise later this year.
‘We’re very pleased with the portfolio,’ he added. ‘It’s taken a bit of a knock in the short term which has been reflected in the NAV coming down in the short term but we’re very confident where it will be in the next three to five years.’
News sponsored by:
After Boris announced he was backing Brexit, sterling suffered its biggest slump in six years. Our Market Mavens discuss. Follow the Market Mavens LinkedIn page for weekly videos, in which our panel of industry experts share their views on financial news
The Citywire guide to investment trusts
In association with Aberdeen Asset Management
More about this:
Look up the investment trusts
Look up the fund managers
More from us
- Woodford to sell Patient blue chips, hails $1bn 'unicorn'
- Woodford must be Patient to earn crust on trust
- Is Woodford biting off more than he can chew?
- Woodford eyes big share issue for Patient Capital
- Woodford Patient Capital starts issuing new shares
- Woodford Patient to issue more shares; reveals stocks
- Investment Trust Watch: Woodford keeps flying
- Broker slaps a 'sell' warning on Woodford Patient Capital
- Woodford Patient Capital shares rise on debut
- Woodford raises record £800m for new trust
- Woodford's new trust reveals performance fee
- Neil Woodford launches no-charge growth trust
- Investors pull £463m from funds in turbulent January
- Woodford intervenes after Northwest allegations
- Broker Cenkos denies SFO probe over Quindell
- Northwest rejects Neil Woodford's ex-FBI candidate
Tools from Citywire Money
From the Forums
Weekly email from The Lolly
Get simple, easy ways to make more from your money. Just enter your email address below
An error occured while subscribing your email. Please try again later.
Thank you for registering for your weekly newsletter from The Lolly.
Keep an eye out for us in your inbox, and please add email@example.com to your safe senders list so we don't get junked.
by Daniel Grote on May 25, 2016 at 13:23