View the article online at http://citywire.co.uk/money/article/a673871
Buxton v Matthews: Schroders swaps one fund star for another
Schroders has poached Philip Matthews, a top-rated manager from rival Jupiter to replace Richard Buson on its UK Alpha Plus fund.
(Update) Schroders may have come up trumps in its search to replace Richard Buxton on its flagship £3 billion Schroder UK Alpha Plus fund.
In a bid to stop more investors following Buxton to Old Mutual, Schroders has poached Philip Matthews from another rival, Jupiter Asset Management. This looks to be a good hire as Matthews currently boasts a top Citywire AAA rating for his three-year record on the Jupiter Growth & Income fund.
The chart below shows Matthews (pictured) has actually beaten Buxton, who currrently has a slightly less impressive Citywire A rating. In the six years since Matthews took over Jupiter Growth & Income he has delivered a 54.7% return compared to 44.5% from Buxton's Schroder UK Alpha Plus fund. Both funds beat the 21.6% average return from funds in the UK All Companies sector in which they sit.
In fact our fund comparison tool shows that Matthews, who will join Schroders in September, delivered a better risk-adjusted return than Buxton over the past five years. Since March 2008 his fund grew investors' money by more (73.6% versus 56.6%) with a lower standard deviation (4.8% versus 6.4%).
Standard deviation is a technical term measuring the amount a fund's monthly returns vary around an average. The bigger the figure the more volatile a fund is. It's one way of indicating risk.
However, longer term Schroder UK Alpha Plus has done better under Buxton (pictured). Our UK All Companies sector stats show over 10 years the fund delivered a total return of 247% placing it 12th out of 180 funds. Jupiter Growth & Income generated 220%, ranking it 32nd.
Stretch back to when Buxton launched the fund in 2002 and he has clearly outperformed the Jupiter fund, which was previously run by Paul Sheehan. His total returns since launch of 224% trounce Jupiter Growth & Income's 139% return over the same period.
Both Schroder UK Alpha Plus and Schroder Growth & Income were recommendations of our Citywire Selection team, although the Schroder fund was put under review when news of Buxton's departure broke. It will likely be reinstated and it may be the Jupiter fund that is put under review until we learn who will replace Matthews. So the wheels of the investment industry merry-go-round turn!
A closer look at the managers show they have different styles, which may influence investors' decisions on whether to hold or fold Buxton's fund.
Buxton launched Schroder UK Alpha Plus to deliver good returns from choppy stock markets. He has typically held between 30 and 35 stocks, with a focus on larger and medium-sized companies. He has not been averse to owning punchy stocks such as the controversial mining company Bumi, and banks such as Barclays, topping up on his position once former chief executive Bob Diamond quit.
In comparison, Matthews has held around 50 to 60 holdings in his Jupiter fund and taken a more defensive approach, focusing on financially robust companies that show high dividend growth.
Ben Willis at Whitechurch Securities said: ‘He's more defensive than Buxton, he’s held up better in down periods, but has lagged in rising markets. He looks for quality companies in undervalued areas.'
He added: ‘I can’t imagine Matthews will try and be a Buxton clone. There’s reason to believe the methodology of that fund will change. Investors might follow Buxton if it’s not looking like the fund they originally bought.'
Mark Dampier, head of research at Hargreaves Lansdown, agreed Schroders was starting again with a good manager who had a different style. However, he favoured Buxton. 'I think that Richard has got more experience and has done a better job.'
Schroders is also hiring Alex Breese from Neptune Investment Management to replace Errol Francis on the Schroder UK Equity fund. Francis is accompanying Buxton to Old Mutual Global Investors in June. This looks like another good appointment as Breese also has a Citywire AAA rating for running the small Neptune UK Special Situations fund .
This has been a busy period for Schroders. Following news of Buxton's departure the group announced it would buy Cazenove Capital to beef up its UK stock market expertise.
News sponsored by:
The Citywire guide to investment trusts
In association with Aberdeen Asset Management
What can SLI bring to the table for those who want to put their money into investment trusts?
More about this:
Look up the funds
- Neptune UK Special Situations C Acc GBP
- Schroder UK Equity Inc
- Jupiter Growth & Income
- Schroder UK Alpha Plus A Acc
Look up the fund managers
More from us
- Investors pull £245m from Buxton fund
- Jittery investors snap up Aberdeen, Schroders
- Schroders swoops on Cazenove after Buxton departure
- Who will replace Schroders' Richard Buxton? We reveal 7 alternatives
- Schroders hires AAA-rated Philip Matthews to replace Richard Buxton
- Chart showing Jupiter Growth & Income v Schroder UK Alpha Plus
- Citywire Selection fund recommendations
- UK All Companies funds league table over 10 years
- Citywire Wealth Manager: don't expect Buxton clone
What others are saying
Tools from Citywire Money
From the Forums
Weekly email from The Lolly
Get simple, easy ways to make more from your money. Just enter your email address below
An error occured while subscribing your email. Please try again later.
Thank you for registering for your weekly newsletter from The Lolly.
Keep an eye out for us in your inbox, and please add firstname.lastname@example.org to your safe senders list so we don't get junked.
by Daniel Grote on Jan 30, 2015 at 17:06