Citywire for Financial Professionals
Share this page:
Stay connected:


Citywire printed articles sponsored by:

View the rest of this gallery online at

The Expert View: Debenhams, RBS and Paragon

A roundup of some of analyst commentary on shares including Moss Bros and Smiths Group.

by Harry Brooks on Dec 17, 2012 at 05:01

Our daily round-up of analyst recommendations and commentary, featuring Debenhams, RBS, Paragon, Moss Bros and Smiths Group.

Key stats
Market capitalisation£1,446m
No. of shares out1,263m
No. of shares floating1,145m
No. of common shareholdersnot stated
No. of employees8355
Trading volume (10 day avg.)4m
Profit before tax£125m
Earnings per share9.77p
Cashflow per share16.92p
Cash per share3.48p

*Correct as at 14 Dec 2012

JP Morgan lifts target price for Debenhams

Georgina Johanan, analyst at JP Morgan, has increased her target price for Debenhams (DEB.L) based on potential for growth in the company's online operation.

'Debenhams has made strong progress in developing its omni-channel offering in recent years but, in our opinion, remains behind best in class,' she said.

A switch to its Peterborough warehouse for online clothes deliveries in spring 2013 should allow Debenhams to add a next-day delivery option, Johanan said, bringing it into line with other leading sites.

'Despite having outperformed by 63% this year the shares continue to trade at a discount to the sector of 25%,' she said. 'This is no longer justified in our view given the structural shift in UK retail and the significantly reduced debt burden. We raise our target price to 144p.'

Shares in the group closed at 114.7p on Friday, up 0.5p or 0.4%.

Key stats
Market capitalisation£34,263m
No. of shares out11,336m
No. of shares floating7,128m
No. of common shareholdersnot stated
No. of employees142800
Trading volume (10 day avg.)8m
Profit before tax£-2,044m
Earnings per share-18.89p
Cashflow per share-1.30p
Cash per share719.13p

*Correct as at 14 Dec 2012

Investec says 'sell' RBS

Ian Gordon, analyst at Investec, has reiterated his 'sell' recommendation on Royal Bank of Scotland (RBS.L), warning its exposure to the Irish mortgage market means there's plenty more suffering ahead.

Thursday's data release from the Central Bank of Ireland gave an indication of what lies ahead. 'In Q3 2012, 90 day+ mortgage arrears (by value) increased to 15.1% (Q2: 14.1%, Q1: 13.3%) which, for the market as a whole, doesn’t even represent a slowing pace of deterioration,' Gordon said.

'RBS has £19 billion of Irish residential mortgages - 60% of which are already in negative equity.'

Although Gordon acknowledged that Ireland accounts for only 10.1% of RBS’s balance sheet, it has contributed 45% (or £9.3 billion) of group impairments over the past 11 quarters.

'It is disappointing that for all the many good things about the RBS turnaround story, the legacy of past mistakes will still be with us for several years to come.,' he added. 'As such, we regret that, for now, we must remain sellers.'

Shares in the group closed at 302.3p on Friday, up 2.1p or 0.7%.

Key stats
Market capitalisation£774m
No. of shares out301m
No. of shares floating292m
No. of common shareholdersnot stated
No. of employees691
Trading volume (10 day avg.)1m
Profit before tax£72m
Earnings per share23.50p
Cashflow per share24.51p
Cash per share167.61p

*Correct as at 14 Dec 2012

UBS downgrades Paragon

Anton Kryachok, analyst at UBS, has downgraded buy-to-let lender Paragon (PAG.L) from 'buy' to 'neutral' following a surge in the shares over the past six months.

Paragon's successful share placement and rising dividends have helped the shares gain more than 70% since May, Kryachok noted.

However, following this rerating the investment debate over Paragon will essentially come down to the pace of buy-to-let lending and the company's ability to improve its return on equity, Kryachok said. These are areas where he expects 'solid but gradual' progress.

Shares in the group closed at 256.2p on Friday, down 5.8p or 2.2%.

Key stats
Market capitalisation£59m
No. of shares out99m
No. of shares floating69m
No. of common shareholdersnot stated
No. of employees976
Trading volume (10 day avg.)0m
Profit before tax£2m
Earnings per share1.53p
Cashflow per share6.61p
Cash per share24.68p

*Correct as at 14 Dec 2012

Seymour Pierce raises target price on Moss Bros

Freddie George, analyst at Seymour Pierce, has increased his target price for smart-clothes specialist Moss Bros (MSB.L) following an encouraging trading update.

In the 19 weeks to 8 December retail like-for-like sales rose 3.7% year-on-year, with sales in the 45 weeks to 8 December 4.9% ahead of last year. Margins also improved as a result of a fall in the price of cotton.

'Following this update, we are raising our FY13 pre-tax profit forecast from £1.5 million to £1.8 million taking earning per share up from 1.5p to 1.8p to bring them more into line with consensus,' George said.

'The turnaround of Moss Bros, the UK’s No 1 branded suit specialist continues on a positive track. However, we believe the recovery is fully reflected in the rating of 31.9x FY13 forecast earnings declining to 19.1x in the following year. We reiterate our Hold recommendation but upgrade our price target from 45p to 55p.'

Shares in the group closed at 59.9p on Friday, up 1.9p or 3.3%.

Key stats
Market capitalisation£4,486m
No. of shares out393m
No. of shares floating391m
No. of common shareholdersnot stated
No. of employees23200
Trading volume (10 day avg.)1m
Profit before tax£257m
Earnings per share64.91p
Cashflow per share101.24p
Cash per share52.35p

*Correct as at 14 Dec 2012

Deutsche Bank upgrades Smiths Group to 'buy'

Martin Wilkie, analyst at Deutsche Bank, has upgraded engineering business Smiths Group (SMIN.L) from 'hold' to 'buy', saying worries about profit margins and excessive market expectations regarding disposals are now receding.

'We think that 2013 could allow Smiths to outline new financial targets, now that cost programs are underway in the underperforming divisions, and that US governmental spending uncertainty should be resolved in Q1,' he said.

'Separately, we think that the template of the Invensys Rail disposal to Siemens suggests disposals for Smiths could come sooner than we'd previously thought.'

Wilkie's target price rises from £11.50 to £13.35.

Shares in the group closed at £11.45 on Friday.

More about this:

Look up the shares

  • The Paragon Group of Companies PLC (PARA.L)
    Register or Sign in to receive email alerts for items in your favourites whenever we write about them
  • Debenhams PLC (DEB.L)
    Register or Sign in to receive email alerts for items in your favourites whenever we write about them
  • Smiths Group PLC (SMIN.L)
    Register or Sign in to receive email alerts for items in your favourites whenever we write about them
  • Moss Bros Group PLC (MOSB.L)
    Register or Sign in to receive email alerts for items in your favourites whenever we write about them
  • Royal Bank of Scotland Group PLC (RBS.L)
    Register or Sign in to receive email alerts for items in your favourites whenever we write about them


More galleries

 See all

leave a comment

Please sign in here or register here to comment. It is free to register and only takes a minute or two.

Sorry, this link is not
quite ready yet