Citywire printed articles sponsored by:
View the article online at http://citywire.co.uk/wealth-manager/article/a564480
Cowley: QE is not working - gilts are effectively worthless
by Stewart Cowley on Feb 08, 2012 at 00:01
It is a vexed question. Interestingly, literally as we write, Adam Posen of the Bank’s monetary policy committee is suggesting in an interview on Bloomberg that, 'It would not be the end of the world were the MPC, as part of its monetary policy efforts, to buy things other than gilts.' This is as much as an admission of failure.
The rumpus over RBS boss Stephen Hester and his bonus (augmented by the disgracing of Fred Goodwin and the removal of his knighthood) has only served to highlight, once more, the problems that have come with the Labour government’s equity investment in the Lloyds Banking Group and Royal Bank of Scotland.
Although there have been three occasions when the share purchases have been in profit, things took a turn for the worse in 2011 and now the UK public is around £13bn offside on the investment.
The government bought shares in Lloyds and RBS with the aim of stabilising the UK financial system, but the loss on the investment highlights the risks.
The US Federal Reserve has bought equities in the past, but buying and selling shares is not a skill-set that is known to be highly developed at the Bank and it is not a realistic option for the next phase of QE – especially when the capital (duration) risks already inside the Bank are already so tangible.
Lifting loans out of the banks may be a way forward which would be to ape the recent program of the European Central Bank to a certain degree. The policy would become: ‘Give us your rubbishy bank loans and we will exchange them for crisp new pounds so that you can go and help the economy’. This must be a tempting thought given the dire state of UK GDP and the prospect of years of government spending restraint to come.
Buy corporate bonds
Instead, the Bank might like to start buying something that would actually help the economy and on which they stand a fighting chance of making a profit – corporate bonds. If QE is really about reducing the cost of capital for private enterprise then there would be no better way of supporting the economy at this time.
Simultaneously, the relatively illiquid corporate bond market would be easier to manipulate and a lot less money would have to be thrown at it to get substantial results.
A further QE program of £50 billion - £75 billion in the corporate bond markets would have a substantially bigger effect than all of the gilt purchases put together.
The problem for the Bank is that they need to get money into the hands of companies which are close to the real economy, companies that will buy UK goods and services and employ UK voters. Not big corporates like Shell or BP, but the type of company typically issuing bonds in the BBB—B area of the credit rating spectrum.
News sponsored by:
Today's top headlines
More about this:
Look up the funds
Look up the shares
Look up the fund managers
Aberdeen Live supplement: Fundamentals point to ongoing flows and solid returns from EMD
After a record year for inflows and market-leading performance in 2012, emerging market debt has taken a large step towards the mainstream. Our recent debate covers the outlook for the asset class this year and where opportunities can be found.