View the article online at http://citywire.co.uk/wealth-manager/article/a580687
Investment Trust Insider: are equity income trusts headed for a downward rerating?
by James Carthew on Apr 13, 2012 at 00:01
For some time it has been a feature of the investment company market that funds with above average dividend yields trade on tighter ratings than others. There are plenty of examples of this across all geographies and asset classes and, generally, it only falls down where investors are nervous about the sustainability of the income stream or the underlying assets.
From April, UK investment companies will be able to distribute realised capital gains as dividends – Laxey is calling for Alliance Trust to do this in the hope that this will narrow its discount. In a tax-neutral environment, rational investors ought to be looking at total returns and the premium ratings for higher yielding companies shouldn’t exist. Are income trusts mispriced and will any mispricing persist?
One of the easiest ways to look at the phenomenon is to compare two funds managed by the same team. Contrast Aberdeen Asian Income trust with Aberdeen New Dawn : both are Asian-focused funds with low to no exposure to Japan, both funds have Hugh Young as the named manager, they are both about the same size (Asian Income is larger with gross assets of £274 million versus. £239 million for New Dawn) but Asian Income yields 3.6% against 1.5% for New Dawn. Asian Income trades at a 5% premium and is regularly issuing new shares; New Dawn is on an 8.5% discount.
A daft situation you might think but, despite having a portfolio designed to generate an above average income, Asian Income is managing to outperform New Dawn on a capital basis as well.
Or how about Henderson High Income (4.2% premium) and Bankers (9.8% discount) – both managed by Alex Crooke at Henderson. Again, the income fund yields about twice that of the generalist (6.2% versus 3%). They are close, but not a perfect match – the income fund is mostly invested in the UK, while Bankers has a global portfolio, albeit with a distinct UK bias.
Again, the income fund has a better capital performance record. If we look at Schroder Asia Pacific versus Schroder Oriental Income , though (1.2% yield versus 3.8%, both are managed by Matthew Dobbs), again, the income fund has outperformed.
This makes me wonder if income funds are in vogue partly because over the past few years the investment environment has favoured more defensive, higher-yielding value plays. If this were the main reason for the disparity in ratings between income and growth funds it would suggest that using capital profits to boost distributions would not, by itself, improve a fund’s rating, you would need to change the investment approach as well.
I could also cite the example of Edinburgh Investment Trust. Distinctly unloved when it was a UK Growth fund managed by Fidelity, the rating improved dramatically when Invesco Perpetual took it on and it moved to the UK Growth & Income sector. Buy-backs stopped overnight. It now trades close to a 7% premium (and should be issuing shares to address this in my opinion). The objective did not change, the dividend has increased since but not dramatically – there was no step change in the payout ratio – the biggest change was in the investment style (which, looking at the relative performance of Edinburgh and Fidelity Special Values , could be said to have paid off).
News sponsored by:
Today's top headlines
The Citywire guide to investment trusts
Investment trusts have proved to be a highly effective way to invest in the market. Citywire has interviewed the experts to find out more.
More about this:
Look up the shares
Look up the investment trusts
- Alliance Trust (Ordinary Share)
- Aberdeen New Dawn (Ordinary Share)
- Henderson Diversified Income (Ordinary Share)
- Bankers (Ordinary Share)
- Schroder Asia Pacific (Ordinary Share)
- Schroder Oriental Income (Ordinary Share)
- Fidelity Special Values (Ordinary Share)
- Investors Capital A Share (Ordinary Share)
- Perpetual Income & Growth (Ordinary Share)
Look up the fund managers
More from us
- It's round two for Laxey-Alliance but investors don't care
- Bankers Investment Trust backs Europe to prosper
On the road
J.P. Morgan Elect on investment growth, income and cash. More information on J.P. Morgan investment trusts.