View the article online at http://citywire.co.uk/wealth-manager/article/a582784
Is Laxey's attack on Alliance justified? Probably
by Simon Elliott on Apr 24, 2012 at 00:01
Last month, Laxey Partners put forward proposals for the board of Alliance Trust to: determine how both investment performance and the discount to net asset value can be improved; examine the possibility of externalising the fund’s investment management; and bring forward proposals that would enable shareholders, who wish to sell, to exit at a share price that ‘more closely reflects net asset value’. These will be voted on at Alliance Trust’s AGM on 27 April.
Tax legislation has changed, from April 2012, which allows realised capital gains to be used to pay dividends. Laxey is proposing that Alliance Trust use these changes to pay a higher dividend, regardless of the portfolio yield, as an alternative to share buybacks in order to tighten its discount.
Last year, Laxey also put proposals to Alliance Trust shareholders at its AGM, including a 10% discount control mechanism. These were defeated but not before the fund had introduced an active buyback programme. Since the start of 2011, Alliance Trust has bought back 81 million shares worth £291 million and equivalent to 12% of the share capital. Katherine Garrett-Cox, CEO of Alliance Trust, says buybacks are now part of the fund’s DNA.
Alliance hits back
Alliance Trust has hit back strongly, refuting Laxey’s criticisms and suggesting the value investor’s proposals will only benefit short-term investors. It also claimed that ‘persistent’ requisitioning was wasting money and estimated that the costs of the defence for both last year’s and this year’s AGM would be £2.5 million.
Are Laxey’s criticisms justified? Probably. Alliance Trust’s performance remains dull at best and there is evidence of a substantial style drift. In addition, despite the buyback programme, the discount remains substantially wider than its peers.
Last year’s intervention led to Alliance Trust consulting widely with its shareholders. This produced a clear message – sort out the discount – which in turn led to the active buyback programme. Although it is hard to see Laxey’s proposals achieving success at the AGM, shareholders will doubtless use the opportunity to express their views. We suspect many would welcome the involvement of an external investment manager.
[Aberdeen founder] Martin Gilbert’s carefully worded comments in the Daily Telegraph recently have led to speculation that Aberdeen AM could be involved. No doubt other fund management groups would look to throw their hat into the ring if an opportunity presented itself.
Where this would leave the rest of Alliance Trust’s business remains to be seen. However, the role of the non-executive members of its board is crucial in this process and this will be a substantial first test for the chair, Karin Forseke. Hopefully, she will keep an open mind in her forthcoming meetings with the owners of the company.
Simon Elliott is head of investment trust research at Winterflood Securities.
News sponsored by:
Ian McVeigh and Steve Davies, managers of Jupiter's UK Growth fund, talk about their predictions for the UK equity space. Click here to watch a series of sponsored interviews with Jupiter's fund managers on the UK equity market.
Today's top headlines
The Citywire guide to investment trusts
Investment trusts have proved to be a highly effective way to invest in the market. Citywire has interviewed the experts to find out more.
More about this:
Look up the investment trusts
More from us
What others are saying
On the road
J.P. Morgan Elect on investment growth, income and cash. More information on J.P. Morgan investment trusts.
by David Campbell on Apr 24, 2014 at 07:48