Wealth Manager - the site for professional investment managers

Register to get unlimited access to all of Citywire’s Fund Manager database. Registration is free and only takes a minute.

Charles Stanley defence shows clash at Brewin Leicester arm with head office

Charles Stanley defence shows clash at Brewin Leicester arm with head office

A 41-page defence document filed in the High Court battle between Brewin Dolphin and Charles Stanley lays bare years of tension between six former employees of Brewin’s Leicester branch and its London HQ over head office policies.

The six quit Brewin last March to join Charles Stanley and launched a Leicester office for the company. Twelve more Brewin staff followed them over the next month. Late last year Brewin issued a writ claiming breach of contract and compensation for damages.

Wealth Manager can reveal the defence of the Leicester six raises a number of key issues for national wealth management firms. It highlights the resistance firms can face to centrally imposed charging structures and diktats over what size of client is viable.

The six said the group’s blanket changes to the charging structure and internal accounting practices had ‘an immediate adverse impact’ on their remuneration, while they were also instructed to jettison long-standing smaller clients, regardless of their relationship with them.

‘They were increasingly concerned that there had been a material shift in the culture of the claimant’s business, from an entrepreneurial and client-focused approach to one of rigidity and prescription with an undue emphasis on shareholder return,’ the defence said.

The document also raises questions over the enforceability of contracts signed by wealth managers. In particular, clauses preventing colleagues from discussing any approaches they have had from rival firms or requiring them to inform the main board whenever an approach has been made.

The six stressed the closeness of the team, several of whom had worked together at multiple companies for periods of up to 25 years, meaning they would inevitably discuss being approached.

They also denied the allegation that they resigned on the same day in a bid to damage Brewin’s Leicester business. Three of the six claim they were in fact asked by Brewin to quit on the same day when it originally poached them as a team from Quilter in 2005.

‘The employee defendants were free to resign their employment with the claimant and to accept employment with a competitor. The departure of the employee defendants was an inevitability by the date of their resignations in March 2013 given their dissatisfaction with the claimant,’ the defence said.

Charles Stanley and the Leicester six also rejected calls for compensation, saying that given some clients had been with the individuals for 15-30 years and included family and friends, ‘such clients would inevitably follow them to a new firm.’

Stephen Ford, head of investment management at Brewin, said: ‘We will always act to protect our business where our clients’ interests have been threatened and where we have been advised that contractual obligations have been broken. We are not able to make any further comment while the matter is subject to court proceedings.’

Charles Stanley declined to comment.

If you have a comment on this story please email cwm@citywire.co.uk

Citywire TV
Play WMR: Why Russia will lose this war

WMR: Why Russia will lose this war

Author and journalist Adam Lebor believes a perfect storm is brewing when it comes to the Russian economy. .

Play WMR: Gerard Lyons warns Asia is the real risk, not Russia & Ukraine

WMR: Gerard Lyons warns Asia is the real risk, not Russia & Ukraine

Chief economic adviser to London mayor Boris Johnson outlines the geo-political risks in Asia and explains why the risk of another eurozone crisis must not be underestimated.

Play Japan's slump, the umbrella revolution and the battle for Brazil

Japan's slump, the umbrella revolution and the battle for Brazil

With the arrows of Abenomics appearing to be missing their targets and political uncertainty rife in Hong Kong and Brazil we take a look at investor sentiment in this week's Investment Pulse

Your Business: Cover Star Club

Profile: The adviser that tempted Robin Minter-Kemp on board

Profile: The adviser that tempted Robin Minter-Kemp on board

It is rare to meet an impassioned individual who is willing to bang the drum for investment advisory right now

Wealth Manager on Twitter