Wealth Manager - the site for professional investment managers

Register to get unlimited access to all of Citywire’s Fund Manager database. Registration is free and only takes a minute.

Colin McLean: it's not too late - the pound weakness opportunity

Colin McLean: it's not too late - the pound weakness opportunity

The risk of a sharp fall in sterling this year is gaining credibility.

A continuing trade deficit, combined with declining North Sea oil production, poses a big challenge and politicians might even encourage a weaker pound to restore competitiveness and revive the UK economy.

That worked immediately after the 2008 financial crisis – this time round, devaluation might not be so readily controlled. Yet so far, the market reaction has been surprisingly muted. Why is it that currencies are so difficult to factor in to investment strategies?

Psychology is certainly at work; many analysts are good with company data, but uncomfortable with currencies. It seems easier to work with the known numbers, rather than a new environment. Behavioural finance recognises this tendency to lock on to the status quo as anchoring.

The timescale for forecasting exchange rates and incorporating them into earnings forecasts does not match the normal company results cycle. Whether companies have overseas earnings, or are exporters or importers, the impact of currency is complex.

Retail strength

Much depends on pricing power and how global the input costs are. It is not always easy to identify the location of the ultimate customer. Since this may take further meetings with the company to determine, it is easy to see why analysts are reluctant to incorporate potential currency moves. It is simply a break with the normal routine.

Why mix up detailed analysis of company numbers, with macroeconomic guesswork?

The recent strength of domestic UK businesses, such as retailers and other consumer sectors, suggests a much lower pound is not yet in market thinking.

A devaluation would squeeze consumers, reversing last year’s pick-up in spending power.

Certainly, a few retailers are being helped by lower competition, but it will be a tough environment for some of the big national chains. Earnings for the general retail sector correlate strongly with the level of sterling, albeit with a delay.

The need for a lower pound was highlighted by the Monetary Policy Committee, which noted that over the past four years, UK costs have risen faster than other countries.

There has not been sufficient internal devaluation of real wages, relative to productivity, to boost competitiveness.

Removing the substantial UK trade deficit against a background of low domestic activity, will involve grabbing a bigger share of world growth. By contrast, some of the southern European nations, and France, could lose out following the recent strength in the euro.

Fortunately, the global economy is still expanding, and exports should benefit from a lower pound. 

Already some of the small and mid cap exporters and those with significant overseas earnings, have been picking up. These could get a real boost if the move accelerates, and the right value of the pound could be at least 15% lower. Parity with the euro is a real possibility. Japan has set a precedent, with a big boost to corporate earnings after the fall in the yen.

The view from the US and Europe seems to be that a run on sterling, along with a challenge to UK government funding, is the inevitable result of its stance on Europe.

But closer integration with a Europe that is simply muddling through its crisis may not be the right strategy. Overseas views on UK prospects look too negative.

Markets that reflect company news instantaneously rarely allow investors the luxury of delay. But there is every sign a weaker pound has not yet been fully factored in to share prices.

The psychological bias that centres forecasts around the status quo has delayed market adjustment. British manufacturers and exporters look undervalued; it is not too late for investors to act.

Colin McLean (pictured) founded SVM, for whom her runs a range of funds.

Leave a comment!

Please sign in or register to comment. It is free to register and only takes a minute or two.
Citywire TV
Brewin's Gutteridge & Foster talk property with Standard Life's Baggaley

Brewin's Gutteridge & Foster talk property with Standard Life's Baggaley

Gutteridge and Foster discuss UK commercial property with Jason Baggaley, manager of the Standard Life Property Income investment trust

Brewin's Gutteridge asks Odey's Tim Bond two tough questions

Brewin's Gutteridge asks Odey's Tim Bond two tough questions

Gutteridge puts the heat on Odey's asset allocation maestro with a couple of tough questions.

Brewin's Foster & Gutteridge: searching for the yield of dreams

Brewin's Foster & Gutteridge: searching for the yield of dreams

Guy Foster and Ben Gutteridge discuss the latest upbeat US payroll report and how it has increased the probability of a first hike in interest rates in June.

Your Business: Cover Star Club

Profile: Creechurch Capital’s CEO on going the extra mile in a crowded market

Profile: Creechurch Capital’s CEO on going the extra mile in a crowded market

Growing a business is the main aim of many company owners but managing that growth in a controlled way is just as important

Wealth Manager on Twitter