Wealth Manager - the site for professional investment managers

Register to get unlimited access to all of Citywire’s Fund Manager database. Registration is free and only takes a minute.

Did Vanguard hand BlackRock a 'monster' gift?

Did Vanguard hand BlackRock a 'monster' gift?

BlackRock recorded a ‘monster’ quarter for exchange traded fund (ETF) flows at the end of last year, leading analysts to question whether Vanguard is taking its foot off the pedal.

In its latest earnings results, BlackRock reported net new business returned to pre-crisis levels, with more than $85 billion in new assets generated in 2012 in its iShares ETF business.

However, analysts at Bernstein Research suggest that perhaps what is less well known is iShares has seen a ‘reversal of fortunes’ in its emerging market ETF product – EEM – which has been losing substantial share to Vanguard’s emerging market product (VWO) over the last few years.

In Q4, iShares’ emerging market product took in $8.9 billion, while Vanguard’s fund, in contrast, had $800 million of outflows.

The shift in flows into emerging markets ETFs, which now leans in favour of iShares, has led the analysts at Bernstein Research to ask if Vanguard has handed BlackRock ‘a gift.’

‘On one hand, the outsized level of flows into EEM might simply suggest increased engagement of institutional investors with the emerging market category - EEM caters more to institutional investors; VWO to retail investors,’ the analysts said.

‘However, EEM's strong December and Q4 flows and VWO's weak flows may also affirm conjecture that some institutional investors might abandon Vanguard's product after it dumped the MSCI indices in October.’

Vanguard said its replacement of MSCI with FTSE benchmarks was partly due to the new index excluding South Korea, which is arguably a developed nation.

‘Yet, as we've noted, the risk/return experience of these two indices has been nearly identical over the last seven years,’ the analysts said. ‘In our view, this affirms that the Vanguard decision was driven almost completely by cost considerations.’

Nonetheless, the move by Vanguard may have been a strategic error. ‘We think many institutional investors continue to view MSCI as the gold standard for international indexing,’ said the analysts.

‘Vanguard arguably expressed a willingness to risk loss of institutional market share to BlackRock with this move. This would seem consistent with Vanguard's focus on being the low-cost provider in the retail market, as well as its capacity as a mutually-owned firm to make decisions more agnostic to bottom line profits,’ they said.

Whether these cost savings are worth the risk of losing accumulation of scale, which also benefits retail ETF investors, is up for debate.

The analysts added: ‘We continue to be concerned that BlackRock will encounter challenges in capturing the faster-growing US retail (buy-and-hold) ETF market segment.’

Leave a comment!

Please sign in or register to comment. It is free to register and only takes a minute or two.
Citywire TV
Play Sam Vecht: the best opportunities in frontier markets

Sam Vecht: the best opportunities in frontier markets

Blackrock's Vecht evaluates frontier markets and explains where he sees the opportunities

Play Where A-rated Pattullo is finding the best bond opportunities

Where A-rated Pattullo is finding the best bond opportunities

Henderson Global Investors head of retail fixed income explains how he is managing his fund against the surprise current monetary policy divergence.

1 Comment Play Taxicab Tenner: Allianz Global Investors' AA-rated Simon Gergel

Taxicab Tenner: Allianz Global Investors' AA-rated Simon Gergel

Our much anticpated new series is here! We hand a black cab driver a tenner and grill the manager of the 125-year Merchants trust until the meter runs out.    

Your Business: Cover Star Club

Profile: meet the duo at the heart of Hargreave Hale's succession plan

Profile: meet the duo at the heart of Hargreave Hale's succession plan

For the first time in the company's history a non-Hargreave is now at the head of the north west broker and asset manager

Wealth Manager on Twitter