Wealth Manager - the site for professional investment managers

Register to get unlimited access to Citywire’s fund manager database. Registration is free and only takes a minute.

Investment Committee: Thesis' Hoggarth on currency

Investment Committee: Thesis' Hoggarth on currency

Thesis Asset Management's head of research, Matthew Hoggarth, on why now is not the time to hedge 'risk-on' sterling.

'Sterling-based investors have had a rough ride over the last 18 months. Currency positioning has been a significant differentiator of portfolio performance, whether the currency linkage has been explicit or via the underlying economic exposure of the equities held.

The range of performance among managers contributing to the ARC GBP Private Client indices has widened, something which has not happened in the dollar and euro indices. Currency positioning is making as much difference to relative returns as asset class views. However, currency exposure is often the result of asset class decisions rather than an active choice.

At Thesis we have always sought to judge currencies separately from asset classes. Occasionally this results in hedging the currency exposure of funds. A few years ago that usually meant working with our chosen manager to launch a hedged unit class of their fund, but hedged unit classes are now much more prevalent which makes it simpler to implement our choices.

We find that hedging decisions are generally most effective when there is a strong conviction on the drivers behind the direction of a currency forecast. Over longer periods the cumulative effect can be neutral as other factors exert themselves. It therefore makes sense to remove a hedge when the initial rationale for it has diminished. This can be annoying from a CGT perspective, because switching to unhedged units triggers the full gain on both the hedge and the underlying assets.

We could avoid this by using a separate hedging instrument; however, on balance we feel that the fund manager is best placed to size the hedge as they know their portfolio best. This is especially significant where constituent companies have international revenues or costs, or may have implemented hedging themselves.

 A different mindset is required when you are thinking as much about a general trend for your home currency as for a view on the direction of each currency pair. I recently spoke to the manager of a Norwegian pension fund, who commiserated with me that sterling has become so easily buffeted about, more like the swings expected from a commodity currency such as the krone. He asked whether we were considering taking a more long-term hedging view and consistently protecting at least part of the portfolio against exchange rate movements.

Opinions differ on the value of long-term hedging. Some studies point to higher risk-adjusted returns from consistent hedging, while others see currency exposure as part of the diversifying benefits of overseas investment. This can certainly be an important factor for sterling portfolios, as a ‘risk-on’ currency like sterling is positively correlated with equities and the economic cycle. It tends to weaken against the dollar, yen and Swiss franc in times of market stress, raising the sterling value of holdings in these currencies.

For now at least, the short term influences are generally political. Sterling certainly looks undervalued against most other Western currencies on a purchasing power basis, but the uncertainty around Brexit is holding it back.

There is potential for further weakness if negotiations falter or monetary policy in other countries tightens faster than expected, but in the medium to long term we expect sterling to strengthen as optimism returns and therefore we do not wish to hedge against it.'

If you would like to take part in the Investment Committee panel, please contact Suzie on sbliss@citywire.co.uk

Leave a comment!

Please sign in or register to comment. It is free to register and only takes a minute or two.
Citywire TV
CIO Tapes 2: two warnings and a lot of optimism

CIO Tapes 2: two warnings and a lot of optimism

Our group of leading asset management CIOs see a lot of opportunities – and overseas investors are buying UK too

Play Wealth Manager Retreat 2017: size isn't everything

Wealth Manager Retreat 2017: size isn't everything

We asked our delegates at the Wealth Manager Retreat what they think about the recent wave of consolidation in the industry.

1 Comment Play CIO Tapes - part 3: 'passive funds are anti-capitalist'

CIO Tapes - part 3: 'passive funds are anti-capitalist'

Citywire recently gathered three of the UK's leading fund investment heads to discuss their hopes, fears and the issues that their jobs throw at them daily.

Read More
Your Business: Cover Star Club

Profile: Thomas Miller explains its post-restructure plans

Profile: Thomas Miller explains its post-restructure plans

Thomas Miller Investment’s (TMI) head of wealth Matt Phillips has strong opinions about many things

Wealth Manager on Twitter
Managing risk, unearthing returns
  • A-rated Beagles sells down Brewin Dolphin
  • Electoral Commission reopens Vote Leave probe
  • City grandee says HBOS crisis 'worst moment' of his career
  • Ex-OMGI duo enters model portfolio market with new boutique
  • Abolish stamp duty: six wealth managers' Budget wish lists
  • James Carthew: is the Japanese glass half full, empty, or illusory?
  • The Expert View: William Hill, Mitie and Xaar
  • Overnight Markets: Tech shares buoy Wall Street
  • Tuesday Papers: May told to exploit Merkel crisis to reduce Brexit bill
  • Investors brush off German government worries
  • Buy-to-let crackdown? Charles Stanley's 5 Budget calls
  • Brewin Dolphin's south west assets hit £1bn
  • Wealth Manager Top 100 2017: seven hidden fund talents to watch
  • Read More