Wealth Manager - the site for professional investment managers

Register to get unlimited access to all of Citywire’s Fund Manager database. Registration is free and only takes a minute.

Neil Woodford v Mark Barnett: how do their numbers compare?

Neil Woodford v Mark Barnett: how do their numbers compare?

Investment is famously motivated by a balance between fear and greed: Neil Woodford’s investors were in many cases in his fund because they appreciated his ability to walk the line between the two.

His flagship mandate, the £14 billion Invesco Perpetual High Income fund, has returned 208% since 1999 versus an IMA UK Equity Income return of 66%. Over that period his deepest drawdown has been -17.49% versus a peer average figure of -23.38%.

That lack of volatility was enough for many investors to forgive the fact that for much of the time within that period – particularly since the 2009 bounce – his compound annual return has run below peer-average.  

Can his replacement Mark Barnett replicate those numbers? Over the last 10 years Barnett lags Woodford by 197% to 218%. He knocks the peer average of 119% out of the ring however.

Over five years – a period in which Woodford has proved resistant to much of the high market-beta momentum which has carried other managers – the situation is reversed, with Barnett returning 90% to 72% versus the peer average of 65.9%.

Over time, Barnett’s drawdown has consistently run a few basis points below Woodford’s – for instance in the depths of 2008 he recorded a maximum discreet loss of 19.89% versus -17.49%.

But equally in recent years he has consistently offered higher compound annual returns – particularly since the beginning of this year as markets have rallied hard globally.

So occasionally more return, consistently a little more risk – although given that is relative to one of the safest pairs of hands in UK equity management, that is probably not cause to start panic selling.   

Leave a comment!

Please sign in or register to comment. It is free to register and only takes a minute or two.

Related Fund Managers

Neil Woodford
Neil Woodford
27/78 in Equity - UK Equity Income (Performance over 3 years) Average Total Return: 59.10%
Mark Barnett
Mark Barnett
9/78 in Equity - UK Equity Income (Performance over 3 years) Average Total Return: 75.29%
Citywire TV
Citywire TV
Citywire TV
Play Where A-rated Pattullo is finding the best bond opportunities

Where A-rated Pattullo is finding the best bond opportunities

Henderson Global Investors head of retail fixed income explains how he is managing his fund against the surprise current monetary policy divergence.

1 Comment Play Taxicab Tenner: Allianz Global Investors' AA-rated Simon Gergel

Taxicab Tenner: Allianz Global Investors' AA-rated Simon Gergel

Our much anticpated new series is here! We hand a black cab driver a tenner and grill the manager of the 125-year Merchants trust until the meter runs out.    

Play Europe bulls, a retail boost and why a little inequality can be a good thing

Europe bulls, a retail boost and why a little inequality can be a good thing

This week’s Investment Pulse looks at whether investors should be bullish on Europe, the surprise rise in UK retail sales and if a little inequality is a good thing.

Your Business: Cover Star Club

Profile: meet the duo at the heart of Hargreave Hale's succession plan

Profile: meet the duo at the heart of Hargreave Hale's succession plan

For the first time in the company's history a non-Hargreave is now at the head of the north west broker and asset manager

Wealth Manager on Twitter