Wealth Manager - the site for professional investment managers

Register to get unlimited access to Citywire’s fund manager database. Registration is free and only takes a minute.

Playboy Club wins £800k damages from bank over credit reference

Playboy Club wins £800k damages from bank over credit reference

The Playboy Club, a casino in London, has been awarded £800,000 in damages from a subsidiary of BNP Paribas over claims that it provided a ‘negligent’ credit reference for one of its clients.

A visitor to the casino, who was believed to be a high net worth individual, applied for £800,000 in credit.

The club sent a standard credit check request to his bank, Banca Nazionale di Lavoro, part of the BNP Paribas group. This sought confirmation from the bank as to the individual’s means, standing and trustworthiness to meet a financial commitment to the extent of £1.6 million.

The bank faxed back a response attesting that its client was ‘financially healthy and capable’ and was ‘trustworthy’ up to that amount.

The Italian bank did not admit that it sent the reply, but in his ruling on the matter His Honour Judge Mackie decided that despite certain inconsistencies ‘in the light of the documents disclosed recently it is clear that it did’.

The casino duly granted the individual a credit line.

However, the court found that in the three months that the client had an account with the bank, it never contained any money.

The bank employee who opened the account for the individual was the same one who had apparently faxed back the credit reference, and the judge established that this member of staff had subsequently been dismissed ‘for irregularities unrelated to this case but similar in kind’.

In awarding the damages, the judge concluded: ‘The bank owed a duty to exercise reasonable skill and care in preparing the reference. That it failed to do. The account had a nil balance. On any view, reasonable skill and care cannot have been exercised. But for the reference, the club would not have advanced a [credit line].’

Leave a comment!

Please sign in or register to comment. It is free to register and only takes a minute or two.
Citywire TV
Play Dispelling the sustainable investing myths

Dispelling the sustainable investing myths

There's a bit of a buzz around sustainable investing at the moment. We speak to three wealth managers to find out what they think.

Play Inside ETFs: positioning for the Fed rate rise

Inside ETFs: positioning for the Fed rate rise

Natalie Fast discusses how investors are using ETFs to position for a rate rise with guests Irene Bauer from Twenty20  Investments and Markit's Simon Colvin.

Play Wealth Manager Retreat: video highlights

Wealth Manager Retreat: video highlights

The UK's leading wealth management talent gathered at our annual event at the Grove celebrate the best in private client portfolio management.

Wealth Manager on Twitter