Wealth Manager - Essential news for investment professionals

Register to get unlimited access to all of Citywire’s Fund Manager database. Registration is free and only takes a minute.

Robert Talbut: Regulation has shifted rather than reduced risk

1
Robert Talbut: Regulation has shifted rather than reduced risk

The impact of the regulatory policy since the financial crisis has been to remove risk from a location where it can be closely monitored and to disperse it throughout the economy, leading overall to a reduced risk appetite.

The focus of attention on the banks has centred on their ability and willingness to lend to small companies whereas the restrictions upon their capacity to provide liquidity to financial markets has been overlooked. The combination of reduced market liquidity (through changes in capital requirements), the herding of investors towards a clear but fragile consensus over future prospects (in large part through policymakers actions) means that riskiness of markets is far greater than might be appreciated.

I would argue that with significantly reduced depth to markets and high congestion of investor positions, the next period of market disruption will be characterised by ‘gaps’ in trading as markets shift 5, 10 or even 20%  in order to reflect new fundamental views. Overall we’re now creating a system with an ‘exit’ which is too narrow to allow investors to use when the next shock arrives.

In such a ‘gapping’ market I’d expect all stocks to fall sharply, even those with assumed higher liquidity. The combination of more volatile and less liquid portfolios with reduced opportunities to outperform is not a great combination for investors but is the consequence of the regulatory approach since the crisis.

The likelihood of more volatile financial markets with more ‘gaps’ in trading is highly likely to act to restrain consumer and corporate confidence leading to a weakening in ‘animal spirits’ and therefore economic activity. This is an example where reducing the level of risk in one part of the financial system is leading to greater risks of volatility in other parts of the system. It should be apparent that in an increasingly interconnected economy the result is the shifting of risk rather than the reduction.

Given the well documented fact that most employment growth and innovation takes place in smaller entities the consequences for growth and general dynamism in the economy are obvious and will become apparent over time. Essentially we will witness a changing corporate structure in developed markets in favour of larger incumbent companies who are better able to cope with increased volatility and risk as a consequence of materially altering the funding mechanisms available to companies.

The choice of regulators appears to be that we wish for fewer big shocks (in banks) but at the expense of lower overall rates of growth and more widespread volatility and uncertainty. While this might be a reasonable public policy outcome I think it advisable that we all understand the consequences of these moves and accept that the lower risk appetite has negative consequences.

One of the biggest conundrums underlying the authority’s intentions is that to return to a ‘normalised’ set of policy settings we require a ‘normal’ economy. The circumstances where we could all identify a normal economy appear very far off.

Robert Talbut is chief investment officer at Royal London Asset Management

Leave a comment!

Please sign in or register to comment. It is free to register and only takes a minute or two.
Citywire TV
Play Sarasin’s Boucher: why I like salmon with chocolate

Sarasin’s Boucher: why I like salmon with chocolate

Henry Boucher, manager of the £129 million Sarasin Food & Agriculture Opportunities fund, explains why he is gobbling up salmon and chocolate stocks.

Play Alibaba hype, the UK slowdown and opportunities in European sovereign bonds

Alibaba hype, the UK slowdown and opportunities in European sovereign bonds

Libby Ashby and leading wealth managers analyse what the Alibaba IPO hype means for Chinese equities, slowing growth of the UK economy and whether there’s anything left to play for in the European sovereign bond market.

Play Tesco, Japan and the rise of the central banker

Tesco, Japan and the rise of the central banker

 Libby Ashby and leading wealth managers scrutinise the food retail sector, Japan’s consumption tax hike and political risk in the markets.

Your Business: Cover Star Club

Veteran banker boosts Sanlam’s stockbroking team

Veteran banker boosts Sanlam’s stockbroking team

A veteran private banker has been recruited by Sanlam Private Investments to strengthen its advisory stockbroking team.

Wealth Manager on Twitter