Wealth Manager - the site for professional investment managers

Register to get unlimited access to all of Citywire’s Fund Manager database. Registration is free and only takes a minute.

S&P loses landmark Australian court case on complex product ratings

S&P loses landmark Australian court case on complex product ratings

Ratings agencies across the globe could come under legal pressure after Standard & Poor’s lost a landmark Australian court case on the ‘misleading’ way it rated complex financial products just before the credit crunch.

S&P, along with ABN Amro, were sued by 12 New South Wales councils which claimed the misleading conduct cost them more than $16 million.  The councils had invested in constant proportion debt obligations (CPDOs), which lost around 90% of their value during the crisis.

The Federal Court ruled that S&P was ‘negligent’ and Justice Jayne Jagot said no competent ratings agency should have given the products such high ratings.

The implications of the 1459-page decision could be wide reaching and could draw in rival ratings agency Fitch and Moody’s. The UK, USA, New Zealand and Netherlands are expected to launch similar lawsuits against S&P.

According to reports S&P plans to appeal and dismissed ‘any suggestions our suggestions were inappropriate’.

Leave a comment!

Please sign in or register to comment. It is free to register and only takes a minute or two.
Citywire TV
Play Commodity conundrum, beleaguered bonds and a US dilemma

Commodity conundrum, beleaguered bonds and a US dilemma

This week’s episode of Investment Pulse looks at the impact of falling commodity prices on banks, dangers of negative yield curves and whether US equities can continue to deliver.

Play Mirabaud's Pyshkin: The US will continue to grow dividends

Mirabaud's Pyshkin: The US will continue to grow dividends

The global equity income manager has invested half of his fund here.

Play Potential US rate rise, cheap oil & the Europe opportunity

Potential US rate rise, cheap oil & the Europe opportunity

This week we analyse the implications of a possible rise in US interest rates, the impact of cheap oil and the European equity opportunity.  

Wealth Manager on Twitter