Wealth Manager - the site for professional investment managers

Register to get unlimited access to Citywire’s fund manager database. Registration is free and only takes a minute.

Threadneedle pens letter to Xstrata expressing Glencore opposition

Threadneedle pens letter to Xstrata expressing Glencore opposition

Iain Richards, head of governance and responsible investment at Threadneedle, has written to the board of Xstrata expressing his ‘disappointment’ over the recommended proposed merger with Glencore.

In the letter, Richards said the whole process that has amounted to this deal has been disappointing and that it undermines the true value of Xstrata.

‘It was with considerable disappointment that we read this morning’s announcement that the proposed merger with Glencore is to be recommended,’ said Richards.

‘The process through which this deal emerged and has been overseen has been deeply disappointing. The apparent target fixation on doing a deal has, to our minds, been at the expense of proper consideration being given to the quality and value imbedded in Xstrata and its good prospects as a stand-alone business.’

He added: ‘The extraordinary executive payments envisaged by the board, firmly incentivising the deal, have done nothing but exacerbate that perception and the related concerns that exist.

Richards emphasised that this deal is effectively seen as a takeover which will mean a ‘significant’ change in culture, leadership, quality and risk profile for Xstrata shareholders.

‘The benefits of doing this deal seem heavily weighted in favour of Glencore, which clearly needs this far more than Xstrata does,’ said Richards.

‘Looking through the short-term fillip the deal offers, giving away the expected future returns on the investment that has been made in Xstrata's business, on the cheap, makes no sense to us or for our clients.

‘Anyone wanting the exposure Glencore offers can access that without need for this transaction.’

He added: ‘As a matter of record, we are firmly opposed to this so-called merger of equals, its terms and its implications.’

Xstrata this morning backed the latest merger offer from Glencore, although it is allowing its shareholders to vote against the retention package without blocking the merger.  This means shareholders can vote for the deal with or without a retention package for Xstrata’s senior managers.

Leave a comment!

Please sign in or register to comment. It is free to register and only takes a minute or two.
Citywire TV
Play Big City Bright Future

Big City Bright Future

Big City Bright Future, the brainchild of BlackRock, is a three-week work experience programme for school leavers looking to forge a career in the City.

Play Kames' Ennett: Trump good for US high yield, but beware Europe

Kames' Ennett: Trump good for US high yield, but beware Europe

Kames Capital’s head of high yield David Ennett believes the changing political landscape will be a positive for the US, but negative for Europe in 2017.

Play Philip Milburn: why inflation won't run out of control

Philip Milburn: why inflation won't run out of control

Kames bond fund manager views inflation as more of 'scare' than a 'problem' and is positioning his portfolios accordingly.

Read More
Your Business: Cover Star Club

Profile: change is the only constant for Quilter Cheviot

Profile: change is the only constant for Quilter Cheviot

This is not the first time we have profiled David Miller, but at the time of his previous appearance his company looked very different.

Wealth Manager on Twitter