Analysts at Citi have reiterated their recommendation to ‘sell’ shares in Hargreaves Lansdown, even though there was ‘much to cheer’ in the broker’s results this week.
Hargreaves Lansdown reported record revenue, profits and assets under administration in the six months to the end of December, with pre-tax profits up 30% to £93.7 million.
The market welcomed the numbers, delivered Wednesday, with shares jumping by some 8% on the day.
They have since given back 1% to end last night on 808.5p, just shy of their 12-month high of 817p.
Citi is advising investors to continue taking profits from the group as it ‘remained concerned’ by the group’s dependence on what it describes as ‘low quality’ revenue, as well as signs of rising cost growth.
The analysts’ earnings per share forecasts – 20% this year and 17% the following – also assume no revenue margin pressure from the retail distribution review. ‘We believe this feasible risk should be reflected in a discounted P/E,’ they added in a note to clients.
Among their chief concerns is rising cost, with operating expenses rising 15% year-on-year, including staff costs up 17%, while marketing and distribution spending was up 22%. ‘With the inclusion of Sipp Loyalty Bonus costs from 1 Jan 2013, we forecast cost growth rises to 21% H2-H2, before returning to 15% FY14,’ the analysts said.
The retail distribution review poses risks, as Hargreaves continues to see no signs of increased competition or pricing pressure in its core Vantage business.
‘It points out that there have ‘always been competitors’ and some have ‘always been cheaper’, and yet [Hargreaves Lansdown] has built its business to a 30% market share of direct to consumer fund sales,’ the analysts said.
‘In contrast, we continue to believe that RDR represents a significant change in the market environment which will change investor behaviour from past historical trends.’
The RDR will also cause margin pressure, due to the greater visibility and customer focus on costs, on all parts of the investment chain.
‘Whilst Hargreaves Lansdown is currently the beneficiary of new RDR rules which force platforms to offer in-specie transfers (i.e. no need to liquidate holdings when transferring assets between platforms), this greater ease of transfer should also, in our view, increase competition for Vantage,' the analysts said.
With the share price at 817p and a target price of 675p, factoring in a dividend yield of 3.4%, the Citi analysts forecast total return of -14% and therefore reiterate their ‘sell’ recommendation.
Conversely, analysts at Charles Stanley say the stock remains a ‘hold’. They said the group's investment in technology and its product range has paid off as it has fed through to assets under administration growth.
'In the most recent reporting season Hargreaves Lansdown has increased assets under administration by 16% in a period when the FTSE All Share is up 7%, due to strong net business inflows,' the analysts pointed out in a note to clients.
'As a result the group has reported record profits and impressively it has achieved positive ‘jaws’ of 10% between revenue and cost growth.'