View the article online at http://citywire.co.uk/wealth-manager/article/a751232
When and why do you dump the laggard funds?
by Robert St George on May 21, 2014 at 11:13
Lockyer is of a similar opinion. ‘We do not want all the funds pointing in the same direction.’ He is one who has stayed with Dobell through his travails. In a small irony, Lockyer feels that if Dobell had modified his approach and so generated better returns in the interim, it would have been a sell signal.
‘In general my instinct is not to sell,’ Morgan concluded. ‘But that is not to say we will hold on to a dog forever.’ He notes that life becomes particularly difficult when clients start querying the rationale for clinging to dud.
So when is it time to walk away from a continued disappointer? Lockyer sells when a fund’s characteristics drift from those that formed the initial investment rationale.
He highlights Hugh Hendry and his Eclectica Absolute Macro as a recent example. ‘The main reason for holding it was that it would hang on in there in a rising market, but would come into its own in a falling market.’
That has ceased to be the case now, though, with Hendry declaring himself a bull late last year. ‘It was not behaving the way we wanted,’ remarked Lockyer. ‘If we hadn’t sold it in the summer, we would have sold it on the back of that.’
Lockyer has also recently exited + rated Stewart Cowley’s Old Mutual Global Strategic Bond fund, which has slipped below average on medium-term views despite still looking strong in the long term. With this fund, Lockyer sold not because Cowley had abandoned his process but because he disagreed with his fundamental predictions of a weak pound and high inflation. ‘If you do not believe in those views, that is a reason to sell.’
When it comes to those whose styles have been out of favour, Morgan counsels waiting to see whether the fund rebounds in the months when such approaches regain popularity. ‘If it is still not performing then, that is the point at which you need to have a serious conversation.’
And what about trading in and out funds rather than buying and holding through thick and thin returns? Morgan observes that doing so is easier than ever now that ‘front-end loads are a thing of the past’.
A-rated Richard Buxton makes no secret of only ever being first or fourth quartile – confident that he is more often in the former camp. ‘It is refreshingly honest,’ commented Morgan. Lockyer concurred: ‘It helps us as a buyer, but it probably does not help Old Mutual.’
Would Morgan move regularly in and out of such funds to try to capture the good times and avoid the leaner spells? He doubts it. ‘To balance that volatility, you might hold a passive fund,’ Morgan proposed instead.
News sponsored by:
As the UK coalition government strives to rebalance the national economy, so called 'reshoring' looks set to play an increasingly important role in economic recovery.
Today's top headlines
With talk on interest rates on the horizon, our latest roundtable debate covers income investing against a changing backdrop
More about this:
Look up the funds
- M&G Recovery I Inc
- Schroder UK Opportunities A Acc Fund
- Jupiter Income Trust
- Invesco Perpetual Income Inc
- CF Eclectica Absolute Macro A EUR Acc
- Old Mutual Global Strategic Bond A EUR Hdg Acc
Look up the shares
Look up the fund managers
On the road